5th Circuit Proxy Voting Ruling: Full Court Says House COVID-Era Rule Was Unconstitutional

The 5th Circuit proxy voting ruling, issued on Nov. 20, 2026, holds that the House of Representatives violated the Constitution when it counted absent members as present by proxy to pass a $1.7 trillion spending bill in December 2022. The full New Orleans-based court split 9-8. For now, the decision blocks federal enforcement of one law, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, against the state of Texas. Most observers expect the fight to reach the Supreme Court, but no appeal has been confirmed yet.

What the Fifth Circuit Decided in Texas v. Blanche

The case is State of Texas v. Blanche, No. 24-10386. Texas argued that the House never validly passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 because a majority of members were not physically present for the vote. Texas asked the court to block only one piece of that package, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act.

The en banc court agreed with Texas. Judge Cory Wilson wrote that the Quorum Clause does not allow proxies to count toward a quorum. In his words, “proxy presence does not count.” The court affirmed a lower-court order that bars the federal government from enforcing the pregnancy law against Texas.

The majority also said its ruling reaches only Texas’s challenge to that one law. That limit is a central point in the debate that followed.

How the Judges Split 9-8

Nine judges joined Wilson’s majority opinion: Chief Judge Jennifer Elrod and Judges Edith Jones, Jerry Smith, Don Willett, James Ho, Andrew Oldham, Stuart Duncan, and Kurt Engelhardt.

Judge James Graves Jr. wrote the dissent. Judges Carl Stewart, Priscilla Richman, Leslie Southwick, Stephen Higginson, Dana Douglas, and Irma Carrillo Ramirez joined him. Judge Catharina Haynes dissented separately and said courts should not reach into the House’s internal business this way.

Why the Court Says Proxy Presence Does Not Count

The Constitution says a majority of each chamber makes a quorum to do business. The majority reasoned that the clause’s text, context, original meaning, and unbroken history all point the same way: members must be present.

The court also rejected the government’s first defense. The enrolled-bill rule treats a signed bill as conclusive proof that it passed properly. The judges said that rule does not apply here because nobody disputes the facts. Everyone agrees the House reached a quorum only by counting hundreds of proxies.

The majority leaned on Supreme Court precedent that is more than 125 years old. It also stressed that Congress had never counted proxies toward a quorum in the 230-plus years before the pandemic. Readers who want the constitutional background can find the Congressional Research Service’s Quorum Clause analysis in the Constitution Annotated.

How the House Ended Up Voting by Proxy

On May 15, 2020, the House adopted House Resolution 965. It let members designate a colleague to vote for them or record their presence during a declared public health emergency. The Speaker could designate periods of 45 days at a time, and the House later renewed the practice.

Congress passed the 2023 spending package on Dec. 23, 2022. The House tally was 225 yeas and 201 nays, with one member voting present and four not voting. Of the 431 votes cast, only 205 came from members in person. Proxies cast the other 226.

A quorum in the 435-member House is 218. Rep. Chip Roy of Texas noted that a physical quorum was missing, and the presiding officer replied that proxy members counted toward the quorum under House rules. No formal objection followed. The Senate then passed the bill and the president signed it.

House Republicans ended proxy voting in January 2023 after taking the majority. Earlier lawsuits against the rule failed on other grounds, mainly the Speech or Debate Clause, which shields lawmakers from suits over legislative acts. The Supreme Court also declined to take up an earlier challenge. Only the House used proxies during the pandemic, and senators kept voting in person.

The Dissent: A New Rule Added to the Constitution?

Judge Graves agreed with the majority on one point: the enrolled-bill rule does not block review. He split from the majority on the merits. He argued that the Constitution’s text, historical practice, and the framers’ intent do not support a new “physical presence” requirement.

Graves also questioned how the court could limit its holding to one law. If the whole bill passed unconstitutionally, he asked, why does the remedy cover only a small slice of it? That question matters for everything below.

Timeline of the Texas Proxy Voting Case

  • Dec. 23, 2022: The House passes the spending package using proxy presence.
  • Feb. 27, 2024: U.S. District Judge James Wesley Hendrix rules for Texas and blocks enforcement of the pregnancy law against the state.
  • Aug. 15, 2025: A divided three-judge panel reverses that order in a 2-1 vote.
  • Jan. 14, 2026: The full court vacates the panel decision and agrees to rehear the case.
  • May 12, 2026: The en banc court hears arguments.
  • Nov. 20, 2026: The en banc court rules 9-8 for Texas.

What the Ruling Means for the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act

The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act took effect on June 27, 2023. It requires covered employers, generally those with 15 or more workers, to provide reasonable accommodations for known limits tied to pregnancy, childbirth, or related conditions. Examples include extra breaks, a stool for a cashier, or schedule changes.

The EEOC’s final rule implementing the law took effect on June 18, 2024. The court’s decision did not rewrite the statute or that rule. It limits federal enforcement against Texas as an employer.

Workers and employers elsewhere should not assume their obligations vanished. Pregnancy protections also come from Title VII, the Americans with Disabilities Act, and many state and local laws. Anyone with a specific situation should check with the EEOC or an employment attorney.

Employers inside the Fifth Circuit, which covers Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi, may try to raise the Quorum Clause argument in future disputes. How courts would treat that argument in private cases remains untested.

Could Other Laws From the 2022 Package Face Challenges?

Possibly, but nothing is confirmed. The 2023 spending package was huge. Legal commentators note that the majority’s reasoning could, in theory, support challenges to other provisions, including the ban on TikTok on government devices and the Electoral Count Reform and Presidential Transition Improvement Act.

The majority stressed that its ruling covers only Texas’s challenge. Other litigants would still need standing, a valid claim, and a court willing to extend the logic. Some scholars also question whether courts should decide Quorum Clause disputes at all, and they expect the Supreme Court to weigh that point.

What Happens Next

Here is what is known and what is not.

Known: The decision is final at the Fifth Circuit level. The usual deadline to ask the Supreme Court for review is 90 days after judgment, which falls around Feb. 18, 2027.

Uncertain: Whether the Justice Department will seek review. The Texas attorney general’s office will also change hands in January after a Democrat won the November race, and the new office may not push the state’s case forward.

Also possible: Congress could pass the pregnancy law again through a vote with a clear in-person quorum. Lawmakers have also floated a narrower proxy option, such as for new parents, and the ruling complicates that idea.

The fuller opinion text should appear on the Fifth Circuit’s published opinions page, where readers can review the majority and dissent in full.

Why the 5th Circuit Proxy Voting Ruling Matters Beyond Texas

This case is about more than one state or one statute. It asks who decides what “present” means for a legislature: the House under its own rules, or the courts under the Constitution. The 9-8 split shows how close and contested that question is.

For now, the decision stands. Watch for a Supreme Court filing, any statement from the Justice Department, and the new Texas attorney general’s next move. Each could change how far this ruling travels.

What do you think: should members of Congress ever be allowed to vote by proxy? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

Leave a Comment